Comfort in Every Bite.

Classic oatmeal cream pies and delightful variations.

Note: We prepare small batches to ensure the highest quality. Limited availability—order ahead to secure your flavors!

The Classic Collection

Classic Oatmeal
Peanut Butter Oatmeal
Lemon Oatmeal
Large Salted Caramel

Standard Pricing

Individual Pie$4.40 / A comforting, hand-crafted treat.

Four-Pack$16.99 / Great for sharing.

Half-Dozen (6)$24.99 / A curated selection.

Full Dozen (12)$47.99 / Choose up to 2 flavors.

Mini Pies (24)$55.00/Two-bite delights. Perfect for events.

How to Order

Inquiry: Submit your request via our online contact form with your date and flavor choices.
Review: I will review your order and confirm availability within 24 hours.
Payment & Confirmation: Orders are not placed on the calendar until the invoice is paid in full.

Important Policy

Note: All oatmeal cream pie orders require a minimum one-week notice once payment is received. This ensures the highest quality and freshness for your small-batch order.